|
|
Because of Ernest Schwiebert’s reference to
the Grouse and Green as a “traditional Yorkshire pattern” in Nymphs (1973), the pattern might
presumably figure into multiple historical texts on North Country fly dressing. Schwiebert makes frequent
reference to North Country and Scottish soft-hackled flies in the
development of modern techniques for dressing nymphal patterns. He attributes
the success of those patterns to the brawling waters of Scotland and the
North Country where anglers dressed and fished them. Such waters are home to many species of caddis flies, which, Schwiebert argues, provides an
imitative corollary that accounts for the success of the flies. Of the three times he
references the Grouse and Green, he attributes it to W. C. Stewart, but
Stewart makes no reference to a soft-hackled or spider Grouse and Green in
his Practical Angler (1857). Later posthumous
editions of Stewart’s book include color plates that depict a Grouse and
Green which is a much more heavily-dressed wet fly than the
characteristically “dour patterns” which Schwiebert suggests must have
“filled his [Stewart's] fly books.”
Schwiebert gives a dressing for the Medium
Dark-Olive Sedge based on the Grouse and Green which he has “modified” in
order “to imitate . . . olive-bodied Macronema
flies," which he discusses in his chapter on Trichoptera: “W. C. Stewart used an [this] ancient border pattern
to imitate similar caddis flies on his beloved Whiteadder, Teviot, and
Tweed.”
Schwiebert’s misattribution is easy—the Grouse and Green does not seem to be mentioned anywhere - Roger Woolley only pairs grouse with claret, yellow, and orange silk in his Modern Trout Flies (1950) -though the hackle and body
combination does in a few very specific instances appear under dressings for the Grouse Hackle. Typically,
soft-hackled patterns using grouse hackles also use an orange body, as in the
Grouse Hackle that William Blacker includes in his Art of Angling (1843). Blacker also includes dressings for a
Partridge or Grouse Hackle utilizing different furs for bodies. One variation calls
for a “Body—hare’s ear fur mixed with olive mohair” to create a green effect.
It also includes a starling wing.
In the Northern
Angler (1837), John Kirkbride also includes various dressings for the
Grouse Hackle, one of which is illustrated above as the Grouse and Green: “It
is made as a hackle, with a small bright mottled feather from the back of a
cock grouse, with a dusky yellow or olive body.”
|